Property concepts and non-mereological semantics in Wolof
نویسنده
چکیده
Property concepts across categories Adjectival meanings—known in the typological literature as property concepts (PCs)—are lexicalized in two ways in the Senegambian language Wolof: i) via stative verbs (PCVs) denoting relations between individuals and properties (1); ii) via mass nouns, denoting the abstract properties themselves (PCNs) (2). (1) PCVs: xonq/njool/bees/baax/rafet red/tall/new/good/pretty (2) PCNs: doole/sago/wërsëk/xel/rafetaay strength/calm/luck/wit/prettiness The latter strategy is widespread in languages which lack an open class of adjectives (Dixon, 1982). It has recently been argued that PCNS cross-linguistically have mass-like substance denotations, establishing a modeltheoretic link between mereological structure and gradable PC meanings (Francez and Koontz-Garboden, 2013) (henceforth F&KG). This paper argues against such a link, and claims that data from Wolof suggest a contrary position: that PC lexemes, regardless of category, are characterized by denoting in nonmereologically ordered domains. Empirical landscape Unlike a predicate nominal like pokal ‘strong person’ (3), a PCN is not predicated of individuals with a copula (4); nor does it predicate directly like a PCV (6). (N.B. the na element, glossed FIN, indicates present temporal orientation with PCVs.) Instead the possessive verb am ‘have’ is semantically required to achieve truth conditions when predicated of an entity. Thus a compositional PCN predicate like in am doole (5) looks indistinguishable from a possessed mass substance noun like am ceeb ‘have rice’ (7) (3) Ali Ali pokal strong.pers. la-∅ COP-3SG ‘Ali is a strong person.’ (4) *Ali Ali doole strength la-∅ COP-3SG Intended: ‘Ali is strong.’ (5) Ali Ali am have na-∅ FN-3S doole strength ‘Ali is strong.’
منابع مشابه
BOOK REVIEWS About a mature theory of Fregean sense
The book develops a theory of Fregean sense to a mature form. It consists of only five chapters, which is perhaps surprising given its volume. The first chapter, “A programme of general semantics”, describes the philosophical foundations of procedural semantics informally and then presents the technical fundamentals of this programme. This chapter is crucial for the comprehension of the book, a...
متن کاملA New Interpretation of the Semantics of "Moral Obligation" from Allame Tabatabaie's Viewpoint
The most important part in analyzing moral concepts includes those used as predicate in moral sentences covering moral concepts of valuation and obligation. Moral concepts in the field of values include those like “good” and “bad” while obligatory concepts include “ought to” and “ought no” and “duty”. Many papers have been written about “moral obligation”; however, dissociating the area of sema...
متن کاملThe Semantics of the Goodness and the Ugly
There are different views concerning the meanings of the most important ethical concepts such as the goodness and the ugly. The author of this article while classifying various views and explaining them, tries to make a critical study of those views as well. Accordingly, first he goes on to examine critically the theory of emotionalists as one of the most important non-cognitive theories. Th...
متن کاملMereological Semantics for Bio-Ontologies
Biomedical ontologies are typically structured in a biaxial way, reflecting both a taxonomic and a mereological order. Common examples such as the Gene Ontology and the Unified Medical Language System (UMLS) excel in terms of coverage but lack an adequate semantics of the mereological relations they incorporate. This shortcoming is particularly evident as far as the (non-)mandatory existence of...
متن کاملHeyting Mereology as a Framework for Spatial Reasoning
In this paper it is shown that Heyting and Co-Heyting mereological systems provide a convenient conceptual framework for spatial reasoning, in which spatial concepts such as connectedness, interior parts, (exterior) contact, and boundary can be defined in a natural and intuitively appealing way. This fact refutes the wide-spread contention that mereology cannot deal with the more advanced aspec...
متن کامل